History●●●●●Difficulty 5 of 5

Did Napoleon end the French Revolution or finish it?

A coup that nearly ended with a bleeding Bonaparte, and a plebiscite whose real yes vote was probably about half the announced one.

▶ Start the story

It depends on what you count as "the Revolution". In the view of most historians, the coup of 18 Brumaire, on 9 November 1799, ended the French Revolution and soon led to Napoleon's coronation as Emperor. But he also kept parts of its programme: he abolished the vestiges of feudalism and enacted equality before the law, while ending directly elected representative government and the free press.

The Directory had lost the population's support over a tax system seen as unfair and rising prices after poor harvests. Sieyès was looking for a sword, a strong man to help restore the Republic in accordance with his vision, without pursuing his own ambitions. Napoleon, who had fired grapeshot on royalist rebels in Paris in 1795, was too young for the Directory itself: the minimum age for directors was 40.

The coup was bloodless, but not smooth. At one point it was only thanks to the swift reaction of Murat and Lefebvre that the dazed and bleeding Napoleon was saved. His brother Lucien addressed the guards, claiming Napoleon had been attacked, and the chamber was forcibly cleared. Napoleon, Sieyès and Ducos became a triumvirate of provisional consuls.

The new constitution tailored the position of First Consul to give Napoleon most of a dictator's powers. It was the first constitution since 1789 without a Declaration of Rights. Lucien announced 3,011,007 yes votes and 1,562 no votes in the plebiscite, figures many accounts still repeat. But in 1972 the historian Claude Langlois showed they had been massively falsified: the true yes vote was probably around 1.55 million.

The plebiscite of 1800: announced vs probable yes votes

million

Bar chart: The plebiscite of 1800: announced vs probable yes votes. (million)
Yes votes (millions)
Announced yes3.01 million
Probable true yes1.55 million
Lucien Bonaparte announced 3,011,007 yes; after Claude Langlois's 1972 study, the true result is thought to be around 1.55 million.

Quiz me

0/3

  1. 1.Why was Napoleon not simply made a director in 1799?
  2. 2.What was unusual about the Constitution of the Year VIII?
  3. 3.What do historians say about the plebiscite result?

Recap

Napoleon's Consulate kept some revolutionary gains but replaced elected government with dictatorship by plebiscite, which is why historians say he ended the Revolution.

💡 A trick to remember it · He kept the law that made everyone equal and took away the elected assembly that made them free.

Surprising fact · The plebiscite announced 3,011,007 yes votes; the true result was probably around 1.55 million.

Sources (3)

No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (18 claims) cites at least one of these.

  1. [1]Coup of 18 Brumaire · Wikipedia
  2. [2]Constitution of the Year VIII · Wikipedia
  3. [3]Napoleon · Wikipedia
More lessons in 🏛 History (3) See all history lessons →

One more light on your map.

Get one lesson like this every day, about the things you love. Free, in two or five minutes.

Get the share card for this lesson ↗