Space●●●●●Difficulty 4 of 5

How did astronauts fix Hubble's flawed mirror in orbit?

Hubble's mirror was ground with astonishing precision, to the wrong shape. The cure was a pair of spectacles fitted by astronauts in orbit.

▶ Start the story

They fitted it with a pair of spectacles. Hubble launched in 1990 with a main mirror that had been ground incorrectly, resulting in spherical aberration, and a servicing mission in 1993 corrected the optics to their intended quality. Because the mirror was wrong in a precisely known way, the cure could be too.

The mistake was tiny and enormous at the same time. The mirror was smooth to about 10 nanometres, yet its outer edge was too flat by about 2,200 nanometres. That made light from the edge of the mirror focus at a different point from light from the centre, and images of point sources spread over a radius of more than one arcsecond instead of the 0.1 arcsecond the design called for. Nearly all the cosmology programmes became essentially impossible, because they needed to see exceptionally faint objects, and a 1991 comedy even showed Hubble alongside the Titanic and the Hindenburg.

Replacing the mirror in orbit was impossible, and bringing the telescope home would have been too costly. But because the mirror had been ground so precisely to the wrong shape, engineers could design new optics with exactly the same error in the opposite sense, to act as "spectacles". Servicing Mission 1 flew on Endeavour in December 1993 and installed them: COSTAR in place of the High Speed Photometer, and a new camera, WFPC2, with its own correction built in. Charles Pellerin, director of the Astrophysics division, had publicly committed to repairing Hubble by 1994, after redirecting $60 million for the mission.

A precise flaw and its cure

The flaw

  • Smooth to about 10 nm
  • Outer edge too flat by about 2,200 nm
  • Spherical aberration: edge and centre focus at different points

The fix

  • Optics with the same error in the opposite sense
  • COSTAR for older instruments
  • WFPC2 with its own internal correction

Quiz me

0/3

  1. 1.What was wrong with Hubble's mirror?
  2. 2.Why were tests not able to catch the error?
  3. 3.Why could engineers correct the flaw with 'spectacles' rather than a new mirror?

Recap

The mirror was ground perfectly to the wrong shape, so the fix was optics with the same error in the opposite sense.

💡 A trick to remember it · Wrong, but wrong exactly: so the cure is a pair of glasses with the opposite prescription.

Surprising fact · A reflective null corrector with one lens 1.3 mm out of place caused the error, and tests that did show the flaw were dismissed.

Sources (1)

No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (16 claims) cites at least one of these.

  1. [1]Hubble Space Telescope · Wikipedia
More lessons in 🌌 Space (3) See all space lessons →

One more light on your map.

Get one lesson like this every day, about the things you love. Free, in two or five minutes.

Get the share card for this lesson ↗