How did Houdini take on the Boston medium 'Margery'?
In 1924 a magazine offered a cash prize to any medium who could prove supernatural powers under test. One contender, a Boston medium, had Sherlock Holmes's creator on her side and Houdini on the committee.
▶ Start the storyIn 1924 the magazine Scientific American offered a prize to any medium who could demonstrate telekinetic ability under scientific controls. One candidate was Mina Crandon, the wife of a wealthy Boston surgeon, who performed as 'Margery' and claimed to channel her dead brother, Walter Stinson. With a doctor as husband, she was well prepared for the challenge, and her charm and lack of interest in personal monetary reward made her seem honest to the public. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the author of Sherlock Holmes, touted her abilities.
The prize committee had a Harvard psychology professor, two psychical researchers, a Technicolor pioneer and Harry Houdini. Houdini turned his energies in the 1920s toward debunking mediums in order to show how they were taking advantage of the bereaved, and his training in magic allowed him to expose frauds who had successfully fooled many scientists and academics. After two sittings, Houdini said Margery had escaped control and stretched her foot to ring a bell in the séance room.
Houdini then asked her to wear a large cabinet-box that prevented her from using her legs, leaving only her head and hands sticking out. The bell rang, but when the lights came on the lid of the cabinet-box had been forced open, and Houdini claimed she had rung the bell herself. Under a stricter control, no paranormal phenomena were observed, and Margery did not win the prize.
23 June 1924
Her husband submits her for the Scientific American prize
23-24 July
Houdini attends two séances and says she rang the bell with her foot
25 August
She is placed in the cabinet-box; the bell rings and the lid is found forced open
27 August
Under strict control, no paranormal phenomena are observed
That was not the end of the argument. Doyle refused to credit any of Houdini's exposés and came to believe that Houdini himself was a powerful spiritualist medium, using those abilities to block the powers of the mediums he supposedly debunked. Houdini turned his efforts into his stage act, reproducing her effects for audiences.
Quiz me
0/3
Recap
Restrict the medium's hands and feet and the spirits went quiet.
💡 A trick to remember it · Tie the feet, mute the spirit: once Margery's legs were locked down, the bell went quiet.
Surprising fact · Conan Doyle believed that Houdini himself was a powerful medium.
Connects to
- ⌚ How did a watchmaker become the father of modern magic?
- 🪑 How did séance tables move when nobody admitted to pushing?
- 🧪 When a magician fools you, do you fail to see it or fail to remember it?
- 🧚 How did two girls fool Conan Doyle and the experts with cardboard fairies?
- 🧭 Why do smart people make the same mistakes in the same way?
Sources (2)
No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (30 claims) cites at least one of these.