What does "no-self" mean in Buddhism?
Buddhism is famous for saying there is no self. But one modern monk calls "there is no self" the granddaddy of fake Buddhist quotes.
▶ Start the storyIn Buddhism, no-self (anattā in Pali) means that nothing has a permanent, unchanging self or essence. The word is built from an, "not", and attā, "self-existent essence". It is one of the Three Marks of Existence, together with dukkha, the unsatisfactoriness of life, and anicca, impermanence.
Step 1: Anicca
Impermanence
Step 2: Dukkha
Suffering, dissatisfaction
Step 3: Anattā
No permanent, unchanging self or essence
It does not simply say "you don't exist". Scholars describe anattā as a strategy to attain non-attachment by recognising everything as impermanent, while staying silent on the ultimate existence of an unchanging essence. The Buddha is also said to have kept rebirth and karmic responsibility: there is no essence, but there is rebirth, and actions have consequences. The Buddhist target is what is called the "'I am' conceit", the root of self-importance and self-centredness, which only the enlightened are free from.
The idea is easiest to see by contrast. Dominant schools of Hinduism assert an Ātman, a pure awareness or witness-consciousness. Peter Harvey notes that in the Buddhist Suttas literally everything, even Nirvana, is seen as non-Self.
And here is the twist. Some scholars, including Richard Gombrich and Alexander Wynne, argue that the Buddha's statements were originally a "not-self" teaching, that is, a teaching about what should not be taken as self, which later hardened into "no-self". In one text the Buddha stays silent when asked whether there is a self. The monk Thanissaro Bhikkhu goes as far as calling "there is no self" the granddaddy of fake Buddhist quotes. Other Buddhist scholars disagree, so this is a live debate within Buddhism.
Quiz me
0/3
Recap
Anattā is read as a strategy for letting go of attachment, but whether it also denies a self altogether is still debated.
💡 A trick to remember it · Anattā: stop gripping the "I". Whether the Buddha also said the "I" is absent is the part still argued over.
Surprising fact · A modern Buddhist monk says "there is no self" is a fake Buddhist quote, since the Buddha stayed silent on the question.
Sources (1)
No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (18 claims) cites at least one of these.